52 Comments

OMG I love this idea! (as a consistently burnt out perfectionist)

Expand full comment

I love anti perfection. When I was growing up I was afraid to dance, sing, do sports, because I was "bad" at them. Now I realize we're bad at everything when we start and maybe we get better, maybe we don't. But I don't want anyone to miss trying something new for fear of judgement!

Expand full comment

Profound and important. You include some great examples. One of my favorite's is Professor Ann Velenchik's description of writing papers: in the end there are two kinds of papers in the world - those that are done and those that are not done.

Expand full comment

This feels a little like restating of the phrase “do the best you can” to “do everything poorly” and I love it. To me, the sentiment feels more like, do what you can, don’t worry about being good at it or doing it perfect, just try. A little is better than nothing at all. Changes it into a bite size piece. I can do this if I don’t feel like I have to do it perfect. Or I can do it the easier way sometimes not always the “right” way. I don’t know, like giving yourself permission to just do what you can in the way you have the capacity for.

Expand full comment

Wow YES, thank you for sharing this! This deeply resonated and I found it encouraging too. I think LEAN OUT is going to be my "word for the year" in 2024!

Expand full comment

I learned not only to do things right, but do them right the FIRST TIME! Lots of unlearning in my adulthood. You can do it well or poorly, and either way change your mind and try again. xo

Expand full comment

I'd say yes, doing certain things poorly is a terrific strategy. Using wrinkled napkins or serving a chocolate bar for dessert is better than stressing over ironing the napkins or making a mille-feuille or not having the party at all. BUT I can't reconcile this with important things in my life: for example, I can't turn in a poorly written book to my editor because they won't accept it and could even cancel my contract. I feel like the approach needs refining. Is there a group of actions this advice works for and some it doesn't? Or is it that you can do some things poorly once or twice—say, being with your child even if you're on your phone, writing one or two bad chapters—but not too many times?

Expand full comment

This idea of doing poorly so that you do reminds me of a series of posts made by comedian Taylor Tomlinson over the summer. She was in a bit of a rough patch and as a way to help herself she decided to attempt to bake a “fancy” cake. She had never baked and her cake looked exactly like someone’s first attempt. It was bad. (This was her opinion.) But she gave the cake to a friend and the friend loved it. And her community rallied around her to support her. She made bad cake after bad cake and everyone applauded her effort. “You made a bad cake. But you also MADE A CAKE! Good for you. Did you enjoy that process? Yes? Then great. Make cake!” Don’t do perfect. Just do. (Nike was right.) A little something we can all do.

Thanks again for another brilliant and thought provoking newsletter.

Expand full comment

Wow, this resonates with me. Not only do I want perfection for myself, I try to “fix” things to make everything perfect for everyone else. It’s exhausting.

Expand full comment

The first part of your post reminds me of the book How to Keep House while Drowning by KC Davis. It’s specifically about cleaning & organizing but gets at a similar sentiment.

Expand full comment

This reminds me of a Jack Gilbert poem, “Failing and Flying”. It’s one of my favorites. One of the lines is “but anything

worth doing is worth doing badly”. Here is a link to read it, it’s gorgeous: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/48132/failing-and-flying

Expand full comment

Beautiful poem. Thanks for sharing the link.

Expand full comment

Love it when your newsletters bite into a contentious idea like this. Your writing feels like a chat among friends. But you're also nudging us to be curious, explore why we might feel what we feel, and disagree (respectfully). Thank you!

Expand full comment

At a previous job we used to pass around a post-it note stating “Better done than good” to whomever needed it the most

Expand full comment

Both my daughter and I have spent our lives NOT starting things because it wasn’t going to be perfect. It broke my heart when she was in the first or second grade and I was shown a sheet she hadn’t completed. There were 3 or 4 simple sentences and the kids were to draw a picture for each. Hers had so much erasure that the paper had practically worn through. I’m going to send her this :)

Expand full comment

When one of my daughters was in grade 6 at school she began not doing homework or doing the homework but not handing it in. She missed out on special school activities as a consequence of refusing to do / hand in her work. She took the ‘punishment’ rather than risk any of her work being incorrect. Being wrong was worse to her than punishments for noncompliance. Her anxiety about getting things ‘wrong’ paralysed her and she wasn’t able to proceed with any further formal education for the next 15 years. Your daughter was so young when she was crippled by perfectionism!

Expand full comment

I think I mostly agree with this but I tend to think of it more as doing the best I can in the moment. If the best at that time is poorly, it has equal value to when the best at that time is something done brilliantly. If one day doing the best I can to feed myself is a slice of cheese and fruit snacks, I have succeeded just as much as another day when I manage to cook myself a meal with all the food groups. It has taken so long to reach this point though. I think for me I need that language of acknowledgment that I am doing my best, whatever that may be at a given point.

Expand full comment

This is so good, thank you. Sara Petersen wrote about ‘practicing mediocrity’ in the context of parenting on her Substack ‘In Pursuit of Clean Countertops’. An important read around the holidays when we often expect so much of ourselves.

Expand full comment